# Two-Sided Dilemma Cards {#two-sided-dilemma-cards} Print these cards on cardstock or heavy paper. Cut along the dotted lines. Distribute one card per pair. --- ## Card 1: Reporting Cheating **Scenario:** Your best friend is cheating on a major test. You know the teacher will fail them if they’re caught. **Should (Reasons For):**

**Shouldn’t (Reasons Against):**

--- ## Card 2: The Lost Wallet **Scenario:** You find a wallet on the sidewalk with $200 cash and ID inside. No one saw you pick it up. **Should (Reasons For):**

**Shouldn’t (Reasons Against):**

--- ## Card 3: Phone Use in Class **Scenario:** You receive an urgent text from a friend during a lecture. The teacher said no phones. **Should (Reasons For):**

**Shouldn’t (Reasons Against):**

--- ## Card 4: Sharing Homework Answers **Scenario:** A classmate asks to copy your completed homework. They promise to credit you. **Should (Reasons For):**

**Shouldn’t (Reasons Against):**

--- ## Card 5: Skipping Practice **Scenario:** You’re exhausted after school. Your coach expects you at practice, but you really need rest. **Should (Reasons For):**

**Shouldn’t (Reasons Against):**

--- ## Card 6: Taking a Small Item **Scenario:** You see a $5 keychain at a store. You could slip it into your pocket and no one would know. **Should (Reasons For):**

**Shouldn’t (Reasons Against):**

--- ## Card 7: Lying to Parents **Scenario:** You want to go to a party your parents wouldn’t approve of. They ask where you’re going. **Should (Reasons For):**

**Shouldn’t (Reasons Against):**

--- ## Card 8: Witnessing Bullying **Scenario:** You see someone being bullied in the hallway. No one else seems willing to intervene. **Should (Reasons For):**

**Shouldn’t (Reasons Against):**

--- ## Card 9: Donating Allowance **Scenario:** You saved $50 from chores. A charity asks for donations but you’ve been saving for a new video game. **Should (Reasons For):**

**Shouldn’t (Reasons Against):**

--- ## Card 10: Feigning Illness **Scenario:** You didn’t study for a big test. You’re tempted to fake a stomachache to skip it. **Should (Reasons For):**

**Shouldn’t (Reasons Against):**

--- ## Card 11: Sneaking into a Restricted Movie **Scenario:** Your friends plan to sneak into a movie rated R without paying. **Should (Reasons For):**

**Shouldn’t (Reasons Against):**

--- ## Card 12: Revealing a Friend’s Secret **Scenario:** A friend confides a personal secret. Another classmate pressures you to share it. **Should (Reasons For):**

**Shouldn’t (Reasons Against):**

---

TROY HOWARD

1 Lessons

Should You or Shouldn’t You?

1 Lessons

Should You or Shouldn’t You?